This is #2 on the list and our contestant for New York style pizza. OK. This joint has a huge following Anthony Bourdain, New York Times, Zagat, Today Show, etc. Heck, it even has it’s own page on Wikipedia. When we arrived there were people waiting in line who ordered their pizzas before the 4:30-6:30 break. And I thought our wait was long. So the question is, was it worth the hype? For me, no. For D, yes. Maybe I would’ve like it more if I hadn’t been absolutely starving. The two of us inhaled our first slices in total silence – full concentration going to just getting food into our seriously depleted bodies. The second slice still didn’t overwhelm (at least not me).
Yes, the pizza was tasty with a good balance of flavor. The crust had a nice char on the bottom (I’m a sucker for a crispy crust), but it was also a greasy mess. We had the Classic Pie which had sausage, onions, fresh basil (all yums), and mushrooms (blech) which would’ve been fine if they stopped there. But they then drizzled some kind of oil over the top – probably the cause of the oil slick. The pie would’ve been better off without the oil. But you gotta eat them as written in our pizza bible. Since we went through so much to eat last night (not to nebtion the $32 pricetag for theĀ pie alone, we took the remaining half back to the hotel with us instead of donating to a disadvantaged New Yorker in need. We refered to it as our precious cargo. Precious (insert voice of Gollum) is now resting safely in our mini-fridge. On the long commute back to D I asked her if she would do it again. We both said no. But I would trek back to coal country for some more Old Forge pizza. Drooling just thinking about it…



